| 查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题 |
| 作者 |
内容 |
sichko
 注册时间: 2008年6月20日 文章: 2475 来自: South West UK
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 6:29 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 6:29 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
sichko wrote:
| peterqd 写道: |
| Oh dear, I hope this interesting topic isn't going to be ruined by a rather pointless disagreement. |
A discussion on this topic was held recently on one of the Photostock Library forums. The question of how far you can stop down, in order to improve DOF, and obtain acceptable sharpness, with or without sharpening , is one which is of interest to some commercial photographers. _________________ John |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
twinquartz
 注册时间: 2012年6月11日 文章: 316 来自: Sweden
Expire: 2013-10-29
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 7:31 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 7:31 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
twinquartz wrote:
Have you tried the calculator I linked to at 11:47 today (see above)? |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
fermy
 注册时间: 2012年2月17日 文章: 1974
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:27 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:27 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
fermy wrote:
| twinquartz 写道: |
| Have you tried the calculator I linked to at 11:47 today (see above)? |
It does not seem to account for diffraction. _________________ Many lenses and some film bodies for sale here: http://forum.mflenses.com/canon-fd-minolta-md-c-mounts-m42-pentax-and-more-t50465.html
Flickr http://www.flickr.com/photos/96060788@N06/ |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
sichko
 注册时间: 2008年6月20日 文章: 2475 来自: South West UK
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:29 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:29 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
sichko wrote:
| twinquartz 写道: |
| Have you tried the calculator I linked to at 11:47 today (see above)? |
Thanks for the link. I prefer dofmaster. It tells us explicity which equations it uses. It doesn't include diffraction effects. I assume that Photozone uses the same equations - but who knows ?
The sample pictures shown at the Photozone site are not very good. There is a change in framing/perspective from one to another. The green stuff in the background looks as though it's blowing in the wind. And have they used a lens which has a uniform performance from f/2.8 to f/11 ? _________________ John |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
martinsmith99
 注册时间: 2008年8月31日 文章: 7029 来自: S Glos, UK
Expire: 2013-11-18
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:35 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:35 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
martinsmith99 wrote:
I use whatever aperture I think I need and can get the results I want on any piece of my equipment. It really comes from experience. _________________ Casual attendance these days |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
Nisseliten
 注册时间: 2012年5月26日 文章: 332 来自: Sweden
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:41 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 8:41 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
Nisseliten wrote:
| martinsmith99 写道: |
| I use whatever aperture I think I need and can get the results I want on any piece of my equipment. It really comes from experience. |
+1
I used to be deathly afraid of anything larger than F/5.6 as that is what everyone told me, then I tried it. Even if my sensor is diffraction limited at 5.6, I can still get better resolution on some lenses at f11 f16 as it uses better parts of the glass. It all comes down to what you are after, and I've never seen an image get truly soft from diffraction. even at F32. I'll blow the shot from lack of light before I blow it from diffraction sharpness. _________________
DSLR: Canon 550D, Panasonic DMC-GF3
SLR: Leica R3mot electronic, Leica R4s, Leica R4mot electronic. and more.
Medium Format: Many.
Lenses
Leica: 19/2.8, 35/2, 35/2.8x2, 50/2, 60/2.8 macro, 90/2, 90/2.8, 180/3.4, 250/4, 500/8 T-Noflexar 400/5.6
Other: When will it end?!
Canon: 50/1.8, 70-200 f4 IS
|
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
skida
 注册时间: 2012年3月2日 文章: 1826 来自: North East England
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 11:23 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 11:23 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
skida wrote:
Yes you can see the effects of diffraction if you blow up a photo enough and then look closely, a bit like going to an exhibition and then looking at details through a jewelers loupe.
I have seen example shots here (and taken some myself) of very busy subjects taken at f1.X and it is so difficult to see the in-focus bit that the whole thing looks like a big blur.
I think too much emphasis is given to wide open shots and wide open sharpness (or lack of it). Orio quite rightly points out that we have much more in our toolbox. |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
Nisseliten
 注册时间: 2012年5月26日 文章: 332 来自: Sweden
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 11:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周六 11月 03, 2012 11:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
Nisseliten wrote:
| skida 写道: |
Yes you can see the effects of diffraction if you blow up a photo enough and then look closely, a bit like going to an exhibition and then looking at details through a jewelers loupe.
I have seen example shots here (and taken some myself) of very busy subjects taken at f1.X and it is so difficult to see the in-focus bit that the whole thing looks like a big blur.
I think too much emphasis is given to wide open shots and wide open sharpness (or lack of it). Orio quite rightly points out that we have much more in our toolbox. |
Anyone going to an exhibition and looking at the images through a jewelers loupe is not seeing the big picture  _________________
DSLR: Canon 550D, Panasonic DMC-GF3
SLR: Leica R3mot electronic, Leica R4s, Leica R4mot electronic. and more.
Medium Format: Many.
Lenses
Leica: 19/2.8, 35/2, 35/2.8x2, 50/2, 60/2.8 macro, 90/2, 90/2.8, 180/3.4, 250/4, 500/8 T-Noflexar 400/5.6
Other: When will it end?!
Canon: 50/1.8, 70-200 f4 IS
|
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
ForenSeil
 注册时间: 2011年4月15日 文章: 2731 来自: Kappeln, Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 3:52 am 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 3:52 am 文章标题: |
|
|
ForenSeil wrote:
Bye the way I believe that some lenses behave better stopped down a lot than others.
I'm not sure anymore which lens it was but I guess it was a Pentacon 30/3.5 which looked very smeary - much more than usual diffraction only. _________________ I'm not a collector, I'm a tester
My camera: Sony A7+Zeiss Sonnar 55/1.8
Current favourite lenses (I have many more):
A few macro-Tominons, Samyang 12/2.8, Noritsu 50.7/9.5, Rodagon 105/5.6 on bellows, Samyang 135/2, Celestron C8 2000mm F10
Most wanted: Samyang 24/1.4, Laowa 100/2.8 2x, Nikon 200/2 ED |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
iangreenhalgh1
 注册时间: 2011年3月18日 文章: 15679
Expire: 2014-01-07
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 4:23 am 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 4:23 am 文章标题: |
|
|
iangreenhalgh1 wrote:
I've never seen a lens perform worse stopped down, if there was one that did, I suspect it was faulty. _________________ I don't care who designed it, who made it or what country it comes from - I just enjoy using it! |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
martinsmith99
 注册时间: 2008年8月31日 文章: 7029 来自: S Glos, UK
Expire: 2013-11-18
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 11:20 am 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 11:20 am 文章标题: |
|
|
martinsmith99 wrote:
| iangreenhalgh1 写道: |
| I've never seen a lens perform worse stopped down, if there was one that did, I suspect it was faulty. |
I think that tends to be pixel peepers or for performance charts. I know where most of my lenses work best (at least from charts) but that doesn't mean I only use the `best' settings. _________________ Casual attendance these days |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
sichko
 注册时间: 2008年6月20日 文章: 2475 来自: South West UK
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 4:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周日 11月 04, 2012 4:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
sichko wrote:
Photozone has reviewed the Zeiss Makro-Planar T* 50mm f/2 ZF. The resolution decreases as the lens is stopped down (EDIT ... after f/4 that is). At f/22 it is about one half of the value obtained at f/4. Photozone says ...
Beyond f/8 diffraction is the limiting factor so even Zeiss cannot fool physics.
Zeiss would appear to agree. Dr H H Nasse of Zeiss has written an article called Depth of Field and Bokeh.
On page 18 of the pdf, Dr Nasse shows a table of DOF calculations for the 50mm Makro-Planar. DOF calculations for different working distances and f-numbers are given. Also given are values for a parameter UF defined as ..
UF is the useful f-stop, where an MTF-figure of 10% for 90 linepairs/mm is achieved due to limitations by diffraction.
For a working distance of ~ 5m, representing a reproduction ratio of 1:100, UF~15. UF decreases as the working distance is decreased.
Dr Nasse goes on ....
This means that even with 24MP full frame cameras there is only a very small loss of sharpness that can still be balanced out with digital edge enhancement. Combinations of scale and f-number that no longer meet this requirement are listed in gray in the table.
All the entries (different working distances) for f/22 are in gray.
My interpretation is that if you work with this lens, the 50mm Makro-Planar, at f/22 diffraction will lead to softening which can't be removed by simple sharpening methods. _________________ John |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
ForenSeil
 注册时间: 2011年4月15日 文章: 2731 来自: Kappeln, Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.
|
 发表于: 周一 11月 05, 2012 4:52 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周一 11月 05, 2012 4:52 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
ForenSeil wrote:
I'm not speaking about a little diffraction-unsharpness, I'm speaking more of a large deacrease in both resolution and clarity, maybe also CAs while stopping down, producing smeary look.
I know that a few lenses have their optimum wide open (CV APO 90/3.5 M39 for example) while already beeing less sharp than other lenses @F5.6 or F8
So not only diffraction is limiting sharpness while stopping down with some lenses _________________ I'm not a collector, I'm a tester
My camera: Sony A7+Zeiss Sonnar 55/1.8
Current favourite lenses (I have many more):
A few macro-Tominons, Samyang 12/2.8, Noritsu 50.7/9.5, Rodagon 105/5.6 on bellows, Samyang 135/2, Celestron C8 2000mm F10
Most wanted: Samyang 24/1.4, Laowa 100/2.8 2x, Nikon 200/2 ED |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
sichko
 注册时间: 2008年6月20日 文章: 2475 来自: South West UK
|
 发表于: 周二 11月 06, 2012 1:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
 发表于: 周二 11月 06, 2012 1:25 pm 文章标题: |
|
|
sichko wrote:
| ForenSeil 写道: |
I'm not speaking about a little diffraction-unsharpness, I'm speaking more of a large deacrease in both resolution and clarity, maybe also CAs while stopping down, producing smeary look.
I know that a few lenses have their optimum wide open (CV APO 90/3.5 M39 for example) while already beeing less sharp than other lenses @F5.6 or F8
So not only diffraction is limiting sharpness while stopping down with some lenses |
I'm not sure that I understand - do you have any reviews/numbers ?
Presumably the CV 90mm is very well corrected wide open - f/3.5 is not very wide. If you take the Zeiss 50mm Makro-Planar, move the aperture ring limiter and paint out "2" and "2.8" you can sell it as an f/4 lens. Centre resolution is now a maximum wide open - at f/4 - and declines as you stop down. Border resolution increases a little as you stop down and then decreases. (These observations are from the Photozone link given in an earlier post). So there's no aberration to correct in the centre and resolution declines because of diffraction. At the borders uncorrected aberrations are removed as you stop down - the resolution goes up - and then the effect of diffraction dominates and the resolution decreases. _________________ John |
|
| 返回顶部 |
|
 |
|
|
|
您不能在本版块发表新主题 您不能回复本版块的主题 您不能编辑自己在版块内的文章 您不能删除自己在版块内的文章 您不能参与本版块的投票
|