MFlenses - 数码时代的新生
MFLenses 2026

手动对焦镜头论坛

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。
精选

论坛首页的合作伙伴展示位。

HP5 v Tri-X
查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题  


Reply

Just developed my 1st roll of Tri-X and I'm quite impressed with it.

The advantages over HP5 seem to be...

1. Slightly thicker film so easier to load in spiral tank
2. Doesn't attract dust
3. No streaks on the negs after drying
4. MUCH less grain

The disadvantage is that the film has a tendency to curl.

I've a few rolls of each left but initial tests look like I may be using more Tri-X than HP5.


Reply

I've always liked Tri-X. T-Max is good stuff too.

Back in the 80s I used to buy some no-name B&W film that a local camera shop sold, was supposedly from Czechoslovakia or some such place. It was very cheap, very contrasty, and also very grainy. I actually liked it quite a lot for the mood it gave. I've never tried pushing Tri-X, perhaps it would render similar results pushed.


Reply

cooltouch 写道:
I've always liked Tri-X. T-Max is good stuff too.

Back in the 80s I used to buy some no-name B&W film that a local camera shop sold, was supposedly from Czechoslovakia or some such place. It was very cheap, very contrasty, and also very grainy. I actually liked it quite a lot for the mood it gave. I've never tried pushing Tri-X, perhaps it would render similar results pushed.

Foma! Available cheap at Freestyle Cool


Reply

Lots of years ago i shot thousands of Tri-X rolls .. i did prefer this Kodak over the HP5 in terms of grain, densitiy and the abillity to "cooking" the film in circumstances of under-exposure, if neccessary.

For me as a former photographer in a news agency, the Tri X was always the best choice for BW Photography in Avaible light condition.
The described behavior tendency in development is correct in a small tank, but we did have big frames in a big tank to develop the films.. not in a small round dose..

Cheers
Henry