MFlenses - 数码时代的新生
MFLenses 2026

手动对焦镜头论坛

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。
精选

论坛首页的合作伙伴展示位。

Defectuous sensor?
查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题  


Reply

Hello everyone,

I sometime see on my photos some dirty things, looking like bad noise. Looks like it happen especialy when there are some nuances of a color. I'm using a Canon 40D.

Here are 2 exemples (both with ISO 100), with 2 different lenses :


Jupiter 11 A


Helios 44 0xxx (13 blades)

On this picture, it's clearly visible on the top.

I only used auto-contrast (on both pictures), no other PP.


What could cause this? I know my sensor is not clean at all, but can a dirty sensor create such things?

Thanks for help,


Reply

Clean the sensor...


Reply

Check the sensor here is a guide to see just how dirty it is you will need photoshop

I noticed that i seem to have a few issues with my camera not being as sharp as it should be. So i set about trying to find a way to check the dirt on the cameras sensor and after finding the best way to do it i thought i would share
Here is what you will need
Camera, a close focusing Lens, Computer, Monitor, and Photoshop
1st things 1st
Set the camera to have no image stabilization, remove D-Range optimization, etc
Set the focus mode to Spot
Now clean the monitor make sure it is nice and clean
make sure the lens is clean on the camera as well
Now open photoshop and create a new file and ensure that it is white
Now set the camera to manual focus and focus on the screen (you can have a page open with text just to ensure that you get focus and then move back to photoshop)
Set the camera to the minimum aperture F22 or higher depending on the lens
Now take a picture of white area only on the screen and ensure to move the camera a bit so that whe know that we are not getting images of dirt on the screen
take the picture we have taken and open in photoshop and do the following
CTRL+SHIFT+L or on mac CMD+SHIFT+L
and you will then see the magical world of your sensor here is mine


Reply

Thanks for answers.

Well, here is mine




But I'm not sure you understood what I'm talking about. I have black spots on picture, and I know it's because of dirty sensor, but I was talking about the kind of ugly thing in the blue, like if sensor is not able to make smooth nuances between different blues. If you understood right, it's ok Smile , just with the test, we (or I?) can only see the black spots.

Reguards,


Reply

Aha! That's the state of my sensor! Shocked

#1

Thanks for the info. Very Happy

We should have a 'bare your sensor thread' Cool


Reply

BurstMox 写道:

... but I was talking about the kind of ugly thing in the blue, like if sensor is not able to make smooth nuances between different blues.


It looks like a phenomenon called posterisation or banding.


Reply

引用:
It looks like a phenomenon called posterisation or banding.


That's exactly what I'm talking about! Thanks Very Happy . I tried to find solution on google, without any real success. It's all about using 16bits, not 8bits, but nothing about preventing it on your camera. My exposure was ok, and quality of jpeg is set on maximum in camera setting Confused .


Reply

BurstMox 写道:
引用:
It looks like a phenomenon called posterisation or banding.


That's exactly what I'm talking about! Thanks Very Happy . I tried to find solution on google, without any real success. It's all about using 16bits, not 8bits, but nothing about preventing it on your camera. My exposure was ok, and quality of jpeg is set on maximum in camera setting Confused .

Can I suggest (i) the use of RAW capture rather than JPEGs - you have more bits to play with, (ii) that if you must use JPEGs then restrict the PP to a minumum - the camera has already done the processing for you, and (iii) that you learn to recognise posterisation and in what kinds of subjects, and under what processing conditions it occurs. I find blocks of "pure" colour - blue skies, red flowers, etc to be particularly susceptible. Excessive use of the sliders - contrast, saturation, brightness - can cause posterisation. I would avoid "auto anything if you can. Also I find that different RAW delevopers and/editors have different likelihoods of producing posterisation.


Reply

BurstMox 写道:
引用:
It looks like a phenomenon called posterisation or banding.


That's exactly what I'm talking about! Thanks Very Happy . I tried to find solution on google, without any real success. It's all about using 16bits, not 8bits, but nothing about preventing it on your camera. My exposure was ok, and quality of jpeg is set on maximum in camera setting Confused .


Don't know how helpful this is, but try shooting RAW. If the problem goes away you know it's something that the camera settings were doing to the JPEGs.

EDIT - lol someone beat me to the punch.


Reply

I tried to find old Raw files where there were this photo situation, but didn't manage to. Then, I'll give a try tomorow.


Reply

Today, the weather is pretty cloudy, so will be hard to reproduce same situation Confused . But while I was browsing the camera's menu, I noticed that I have set up the "Color space" (I don't know the correct translation to english) to Adobe RVB, whereas usual setting should be sRVB. Could it be related to my problem? I have compared 2 test shots (aprox. same situation) with the 2 settings, looks more contrasty on AdobeRVB.


AdobeRVB:


sRVB:


Reply

BurstMox 写道:
Today, the weather is pretty cloudy, so will be hard to reproduce same situation Confused . But while I was browsing the camera's menu, I noticed that I have set up the "Color space" (I don't know the correct translation to english) to Adobe RVB, whereas usual setting should be sRVB. Could it be related to my problem? I have compared 2 test shots (aprox. same situation) with the 2 settings, looks more contrasty on AdobeRVB.


Are these captures JPEGS ? If you use RAW you don't have to choose the Colour Space (Yes it's the correct term - "Color" - American English; "Colour" - UK English) until you do the conversion/editing. You could take one shot and convert/edit using the two different Colour Spaces. This would guarantee identical exposures and framing.

Looking at the two pictures ("Big" versions) I can see banding in the top left hand corners. It's more obvious in the AdobeRGB picture (Note: RVB (rouge, vert, bleu) en Français RVB = RGB (red, green, blue) in English). The AdobeRGB colour space is bigger than sRGB. Given the same bit depth, ie, the number of possible colours, and everthing else being equal, it is more likely to lead to banding.


Reply

Yes, those pictures are JPEG generated by camera. Today, I've made some shots in Paris in RAW/JPEG , but I didn't managed to get this bending "effect", so I can't compare.

Now, I just fear to become maniac about this bending, looking for it in every pictures Very Happy . I'll shot in Raw in futur, let see if this thing happen again.

@sichko : Thx for colour space explanation, now everything is clear.