MFlenses - 数码时代的新生
MFLenses 2026

手动对焦镜头论坛

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。
精选

论坛首页的合作伙伴展示位。

Light meter readings
查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题  


Reply

With incidental light readings I am not sure where you should be pointing the meter. take the following examples X is the subject with the sun in positions A B and C (and there's me, minus a few pounds with my Kowa!)




I have read that you point the domed incident light meter at the camera
With the sun behind the camera A I can see how that would hold true

But hwen the sun is in position B and C surely pointing the dome at the camera is going to result in shadow falling on the dome and a false reading? Or do you point the meter at the light source? (2 and 3)
Confused Confused


Reply

With the dome on, you stand where the subject is and face the camera, so you're reading the actual light that's falling on the subject and being reflected towards the camera.
Without the dome on, you simply act as the camera.

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tutorials/meters.shtml#A%20Tutorial%20on%20Incident%20Metering


Reply

Yes I can see that but if the light source is behind the subject (ie C) and you point at the camera then the dome will be in the shadow of the meter. Is that still how you would meter it?


Reply

Bob,

it is totally irrelevant if the light cell is under the shadow of the meter body: whatever happens behind it, shadow or whatever else, does not matter to it. Because, the whole point of using this type of metering is to get rid of the object-related problems in the metering - and this includes shadows, together with colours, reflections, refractions, etc.

If you prefer you can simplify it that way: when doing incident light metering, the object (and the light meter that takes its place) does not exist.

-


Reply

Or, you can think of it as a big old mixing bowl of light...it's all mixed together when you take an incident reading. So, Orio is showing a good analogy, that you don't have to worry if the meter is in light or shade...the dome is simply reading the whole "mix" of colors in the bowl.


Reply

Laurence 写道:
Or, you can think of it as a big old mixing bowl of light...it's all mixed together when you take an incident reading. So, Orio is showing a good analogy, that you don't have to worry if the meter is in light or shade...the dome is simply reading the whole "mix" of colors in the bowl.


Actually the point is that, when you are going to photograph a bowl, the light meter becomes the bowl.
It's like the bowl had eyes and could read the light around it self (in the viewing angle of the light meter of course)

Direct metering: the meter measures the light reflected from the bowl

Indirect (incident) metering: the meter becomes the bowl and measures the light around it self within the limit of its viewing angle.


Reply

Orio 写道:
Laurence 写道:
Or, you can think of it as a big old mixing bowl of light...it's all mixed together when you take an incident reading. So, Orio is showing a good analogy, that you don't have to worry if the meter is in light or shade...the dome is simply reading the whole "mix" of colors in the bowl.


Actually the point is that, when you are going to photograph a bowl, the light meter becomes the bowl.
It's like the bowl had eyes and could read the light around it self (in the viewing angle of the light meter of course)

Direct metering: the meter measures the light reflected from the bowl

Indirect (incident) metering: the meter becomes the bowl and measures the light around it self within the limit of its viewing angle.


You NAILED it! Perfect explanation. Smile


Reply

hacksawbob 写道:
Yes I can see that but if the light source is behind the subject (ie C) and you point at the camera then the dome will be in the shadow of the meter. Is that still how you would meter it?


If the subject was big enough, yes, for you would be wanting to expose for the front of the subject anyway, which would be in shadow too.
I've found that no meter is 100% foolproof - well they are; they prove that we are fools a lot of the time- but it's really just getting familiar with it and realising that the LM gives a guide, a starting point, not necessarily a hard and fast rule. The more you use it, the better it gets Wink
That's the magical thing about digital, you can click away while learning the use of the LM and it's not cost a bean. It's bloody expensive doing the same with film.


Reply

Farside 写道:

I've found that no meter is 100% foolproof


I know that many expert support the indirect (incident) metering.
However, for most practical uses, I found it unnecessarily awkward.
Not always we have the time or the physical possibility to reach the point of our target to do the metering. Try to do that when photographing a mountain top, for instance. Or a horse race.
Yes, we can make approximation, if we are standing on a place that more or less receives the same amount of light than the target area. But in that case, a compromise is a compromise, so it's easier just to make another kind of compromise, that is faster.
If a photographer is an average experienced one, he can just go with direct metering. In front of a landscape, for instance, he will know where to meter in order to obtain a good average, even if he does not want to make a full average sample number of 4-5 meterings like they teach you.
I personally do not even do that, and prefer to make a simple "grey card substitute" metering my measuring the light reflected from the palm of my hand, placing in in a sunny or shade position depending if in my target image the sunny or shade parts are more important - or sometimes measuring both and averaging. This might not be the most scientifical way, but I rarely (if ever) missed a shot this way. This is an especially useful way when you are shooting live events, where people might move fast from sunlight to shade. You set the camera to manual mode, choose a needed time (in my case it's 1/250), make an average metering on the palm of the hands, then go with it, in mid day you are usually able to go on with it quite some time before you readjust. Near sunrise or sunset you need of course to readjust much often.
There are, lastly, cases, like closeup photographing, especially of bright subjects over dark backgrounds (like bright flowers), where you really need to do a spot metering and no other metering is really enough accurate.


Reply

Orio 写道:
I know that many expert support the indirect (incident) metering. However, for most practical uses, I found it unnecessarily awkward....


Absolutely - me too!

Bob, with the sun in position C on your sketch, taking a direct meter reading from the camera position will compensate for the sunlight, resulting in the subject being under-exposed. The same happens with, say, a shot of someone skiing with snow in the background. The reverse can happen when you shoot a bride in a white dress against a dark background. The meter will over-expose the dress because it's trying to pick up detail in the shadows. Incident metering measures the light falling onto the subject, not reflected from it, so in the backlit situation pointing the dome at the sun would also result in underexposure of the subject. The camera will see only the shadow side of the subject, so you need to measure the shadows.

However, incident metering is not precise - it takes a more general reading. Unless you're using a spot meter, the best way to ensure you get the exposure you want in either case is to go right up close to the subject and measure only the reflected light, excluding as much of the background as possible.


Reply

Thanks for that explanation, I'll give it a try. I have been spot-metering at the moment and guessing on a balance.

Next question?

Can I use my digital to provide a Polaroid type metering of the scene, will I need to use the same focal length lens presumably?


Reply

hacksawbob 写道:
Can I use my digital to provide a Polaroid type metering of the scene, will I need to use the same focal length lens presumably?


Yes, many people use their digicams for metering. I don't trust mine a lot though Shocked I agree with what Dave said, the best way to get the feel of using the hand-held meter is to take a reading of a shot from the camera position, set your lens aperture and ther ISO and shutter speed on your DSLR (in manual mode) according to the light meter, and see how the picture turns out. Take hundreds of shots if necessary, it's cheap!! Smile


Reply

Here's a very helpful page about using lightmeters from Kodak:
http://www.kodak.com/cluster/global/en/consumer/products/techInfo/af9/index.shtml


Reply

Orio 写道:
I personally do not even do that, and prefer to make a simple "grey card substitute" metering my measuring the light reflected from the palm of my hand, placing in in a sunny or shade position depending if in my target image the sunny or shade parts are more important - or sometimes measuring both and averaging. This might not be the most scientifical way, but I rarely (if ever) missed a shot this way. This is an especially useful way when you are shooting live events, where people might move fast from sunlight to shade. You set the camera to manual mode, choose a needed time (in my case it's 1/250), make an average metering on the palm of the hands, then go with it, in mid day you are usually able to go on with it quite some time before you readjust. Near sunrise or sunset you need of course to readjust much often.


I used to do that a lot and it worked very well indeed.


Reply

Today I tried both metering methods reflective and incidental, my incedental readings always seemed much lower (less light) than my reflective.