MFlenses - 数码时代的新生
MFLenses 2026

手动对焦镜头论坛

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。
精选

论坛首页的合作伙伴展示位。

Canon EOS 5DII or Sony NEX-7?
查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题  


Reply

Putting price difference and sensor size aside, for those of us with a sizeable collection of legacy mf glass, which would you choose and why?


Reply

I would always choose a full frame camera because it's the only way you can really get the real character from a full frame lens.
In the centre of the frame, most lenses tend to look the same.
Things like OOF transition, curvature of field (which plays an important role in the "3D" effect), and 90% of a lens defects too, lie
in the portion of the frame that is not recorded by a crop camera.

Of course, this assumed that your main purpose would be to "enjoy your lenses".
If instead you have other photograph priorities, those will have to determine your choices (e.g. you like to photograph during travels? The small size of a Nex is the winner.
You like to take portraits? The immediacy of a reflex is your best bet).


Reply

Also keep in mind that the Nex would enable you to use almost any type of lens on the market including RF,SRL and medium format, cine etx. lense Smile Also there is more space for experiments with the nex.


Reply

I use my NEX almost exclusively with MF lenses, I think the AF kit lens has been on it twice. My K10 I now use with the AF DA50-135 just about all the time, and I enjoy using a good AF lens on the K10. But today I have had a Takumar 200 on it and had some good results.
I just can't see me ever buying another DSLR with the intention of using mainly MF lenses, but I will upgrade my NEX for them. Before I had the NEX I used mainly MF lenses on the K10, but I get better results with the NEX.
But of course, the full frame factor will change the way the old MF glass performs on the Canon?


Reply

One nex and one FF should cover all you need.

FF is used with 28/2 and wider, or portrait work.
If you have a distagon 15/3.5, you need a FF.

I also keep a pentax body for long focals due to its SR build-in, which is awesome good for 2-300mm and longer.

If fund is not an issue, I would get a sony FF to use with zeiss 135/1.8 (and vario sonnar 24-70/2.8, perhaps 135 stf) or
a nikon FF for use with nikkor DC lenses and AF tracking of fast object, but I prefer a canon FF.


Reply

Orio 写道:
I would always choose a full frame camera because it's the only way you can really get the real character from a full frame lens.
In the centre of the frame, most lenses tend to look the same.
Things like OOF transition, curvature of field (which plays an important role in the "3D" effect), and 90% of a lens defects too, lie
in the portion of the frame that is not recorded by a crop camera.

Of course, this assumed that your main purpose would be to "enjoy your lenses".
If instead you have other photograph priorities, those will have to determine your choices (e.g. you like to photograph during travels? The small size of a Nex is the winner.
You like to take portraits? The immediacy of a reflex is your best bet).

+1


Reply

Where will you display your photos, paper printed or any kind of digital canvas? What's size?

Renato


Reply

Putting sensor size aside, I would buy a nex-7 without exitation.
The point is that, imho, sensor size is a very relevant difference (the most relevant one, probably), and putting it aside can be a bit misleading.


Reply

If I were mainly using manual lenses, I would go with the DSLR which will balance nicely with all lenses. Big lenses on a Nex doesn't work well IMO.


Reply

The 5DII looks like an obvious choice for the sensor, but if I had an extensive collection of MF lenses the words "focus peaking" would be causing enough doubt to make me seriously consider the NEX-7. With rumours of a full-frame NEX camera due this year (NEX-9), I might wait it out and see.


Reply

-NEX 7 is imho better with manual lenses do much better compatibility (Minolta MD, Canon FD, Konica AR, Leica M,...)
-NEX-7 is much more compact and has better live-view
-If you're not highly interested in these go for 5DMKII - A FF sensor rocks!

PS
-I guess FF NEX will cost around 3000€


Reply

ManualFocus-G 写道:
If I were mainly using manual lenses, I would go with the DSLR which will balance nicely with all lenses. Big lenses on a Nex doesn't work well IMO.


I actually think the opposite is true, the NEX on a big MF lens is better than a DSLR, treat it and handle it as a lens with a camera on the back, instead of a camera with a lens on the front. Being able to hold the lens at waist height, prop the whole thing on a fence post or something, just makes big heavy lenses so much easier to use with a NEX. I guess it's a frame of mind, and giving up all our old traditions. Wink


Reply

Lloydy 写道:
ManualFocus-G 写道:
If I were mainly using manual lenses, I would go with the DSLR which will balance nicely with all lenses. Big lenses on a Nex doesn't work well IMO.


I actually think the opposite is true, the NEX on a big MF lens is better than a DSLR, treat it and handle it as a lens with a camera on the back, instead of a camera with a lens on the front. Being able to hold the lens at waist height, prop the whole thing on a fence post or something, just makes big heavy lenses so much easier to use with a NEX. I guess it's a frame of mind, and giving up all our old traditions. Wink


Fair enough for static use, but I struggled to use the Nex with bigger lenses handheld, which is how I do most of my shooting.


Reply

I still get bewildered by the nex in quick street shooting...


Reply

...and with the 7D body going for $1,770 I'd think the 5DII used prices should get downward pressure.


Reply

hoanpham 写道:
One nex and one FF should cover all you need.


My apologies to everyone for not replying to your reply's until now. I tend to agree with Hoanpham's statement above. I've recently been selling off some of my equipment (mostly cameras and a few lenses) and for digital use have decided just to keep my 5DMKII and NEX5N c/w EVF.