MFlenses - 数码时代的新生
MFLenses 2026

手动对焦镜头论坛

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。

通过维修记录、实拍样片和图文丰富的档案帖,探索老镜头的世界。
精选

论坛首页的合作伙伴展示位。

Which Medium Format would you get?
查看上一个主题 :: 查看下一个主题  


Reply

I need some advice because I'm considering some cameras with which I have no experience.

First off, I don't have a lot to spend on this. If I had a bit more, I know what I'd get -- a Bronica SQA or SQAi with metered finder, back(s), and lens. But they're going for more than I can afford.

I have always liked the Yashica Mat TLRs, and the 124 (not the G) is on the top of my list. It's usually affordable, and takes great photos.

But there's this whole other world out there that I'm not familiar with: the Pentacon/Praktica/Keiv 66 cameras and the Kiev 88s. I've heard generally good things about these cameras over the years.

Now, I understand that some models have MLU. That's a big plus, considering the size of a 6x6 mirror. And some are 12-24 capable too.

So, I guess what I'd like to know is, which way would you go if you had to choose between the various East German/Ukranian cameras and a TLR like the Yashica Mat? And most important -- other than the obvious, which is interchangeable lenses, why would you make this choice? Or is lens interchangeability the major reason why you would choose one of the SLRs? And if you would choose an SLR, which one is your preference? I'm specifically interested in any reason why one would prefer one of the Pentacon-style cameras over one like the Kiev 88, for example.

Thanks!


Reply

Pentacon Six is 6x6 and can have frame spacing issues; specifically frame overlap and I've read of problems with the shutter speeds all being 1/125 sec. Orio has/had a P6 and had frame spacing problems, my P6 on the other hand does not.

One lens will probably never be enough if you go down the P6 route and you're talking to someone that knows... Laughing I ended up with Flektogons 50 and 65, Biometars 80 and 120 and Sonnars 180 and 300, never mind the meter prism and extension tubes... The complete P6 kit lives in a Lowepro Commercial AW that's almost as big as a small garden shed as I can get everything in it apart from the lens hoods.

Which equals heavy.

Pros of an SLR like the P6 is that you can use the P6 lenses on DSLRs and other 35mm bodies as a bonus so you have even more flexibility than it already delivers.

Cons of an SLR are mainly weight related.

TLR wise, I have a Yashica 635 TLR that is also 6x6 and while it reputedly doesn't have as good a lens as the 124, is still a fine camera in it's own right - just don't ever use the self-timer on these as it apparently locks up the shutter if it breaks - or so I've read. That said, I've used the self-timer many times on mine and the camera still works like a dream.

Pros of a TLR are that it's cheap(ish), relatively discreet and lightweight.

Cons are mainly the fixed lens but that depends on the shooter and subject.

I also have a Mamiya RB67 Pro-S (6x7) with 50,65, 127 and 180mm lenses - this is a monster setup and is possibly out of your reach.

If you've never shot medium format before, then I suggest you start with a TLR as it's a cheap way into it and if you don't like medium format (unlikely...), you haven't spent too much. If you then find you need lens interchangeability, you can head into P6 territory bearing in mind the provisos above. One thing they'll all deliver though is impeccable IQ irrespective of what you choose.

Prepare to be amazed...


最后由 bob955i 于 周日 12月 06, 2009 8:34 pm 编辑;共编辑 2 次


Reply

I have limited experience with cameras, from my experience I prefer Pentax 645 and old quality folders.

My favorite sets are:

Pentax 645+ P6 adapter + Carl Zeiss Jena Flektogon 50mm, CZJ Biometar 120mm + 80mm and many other P6 lenses for sure.

I am not a TLR fan I did try Yashica MAT, Yashica 124G, Rolleiflex they are good ones , but I like P645 better.

If you need truly amazing picture quality , try Bessa folders with next lenses:

Skopar, Heliar, Color-Skopar,Color-Heliar

I did try all and decide to keep Heliar and Color-Skopar, all are excellent for sure .


My next targeted camera is Koni-Omega I never seen better shoots what that camera produced by Bill.

Finally try to take a Konica Pearl unbelievable small and it's IQ simple amazing.


http://www.mflenses.com/gallery/v/filmcamera/japanese/pentax_645/
http://www.mflenses.com/gallery/v/filmcamera/japanese/pentax_645_001/
http://www.mflenses.com/gallery/v/filmcamera/german/Voigtlander/BessaRF/
http://www.mflenses.com/gallery/v/filmcamera/german/Voigtlander/bessa_rf_heliar_latest/
etc...


Reply

Pentacon 6 and its legacy had a few mechanical issues and severe build quality problems - the same goes for Kievs. If you want a reliable P6 mount 6x6 camera body, West German and Ukrainian companies have sold modified P6 (Exakta 66) and Kiev 60 (Arax) bodies which corrected these flaws. These are somewhat rare on the used market and not cheap - since prices for used, more modern MF cameras have dropped severely they are a rather poor deal nowadays.

If square format is no must, I'd recommend get a more modern 645 body and adapter. I can vouch for the quality of the Pentax 645, Mamiya M645 (all except for the M645super - the shutter electronics and film transport on that model were flawed) and Zenza Bronica ETRS.


Reply

bob955i 写道:
If you've never shot medium format before, then I suggest you start with a TLR as it's a cheap way into it and if you don't like medium format (unlikely...), you haven't spent too much. If you then find you need lens interchangeability, you can head into P6 territory bearing in mind the provisos above. One thing they'll all deliver though is impeccable IQ irrespective of what you choose.


Thanks for the feedback, guys.

Actually, I do have a fair amount of experience with medium format. I used to own a Bronica EC-TL with several lenses and backs, and it was a great camera. Those old Nikkors and Zenzanons took amazingly sharp photos.

I've also owned a couple of Super Ikontas -- a B and a BX, both with coated lenses and Synchro Compur shutters. Wish I never would have sold them.

And I've owned several TLRs -- my first was a Yashica Mat 124G. But I've owned four or five Rolleiflexes too, both 3.5s and 2.8s. The one of those I used the most was an Automat with a 3.5 Schneider. It was a great camera.

I'm leaning away from 645. I might consider 6x7 if I could find an outfit within my budget, which is doubtful. I actually like the 6x6 format, so my next MF purchase will most likely be a 6x6 -- unless I fall into an incredible deal like Paul C did the other day . . .

I guess I should check into the Bessa folders too. When I've looked at them in the past on eBay though, it seems that they're up there with the good Super Ikontas, which is generally outside my budget range.

However, regardless of which way I go, I have two basic requirements: x-sync and some means of focusing the lens. I'm not interested in cameras that do not have x-sync or use range focusing.


Reply

I bought my Pentax 645 fairly cheap too and they are very common. I remember around 145 USD with two inserts 120 and 220.


Reply

That's a very good price. There are a couple Pentax 645 outfits on eBay right now for close to that, but still with about a day to go before auction close, I'm sure they'll go for more.

If I go with 645, probably the cheapest route will be with the Bronica ETRSi (it has MLU so this is the one I'd want).

I've been watching medium format prices for over a year now, and it seems like they've bottomed out and are on the rise. Has anyone else noticed this?


Reply

Don't know perhaps... Some people start to learn ... at some areas slides still better than any digital and cost is lot less than top DSLR. I think P645 is a really good deal almost small as big 35mm SLR and image quality is lot more better. 6x7 MF SLR are bulky heavy items for amateurs.


Reply

I think the advantage of shooting slides or even negatives with MF is that because they are so much bigger, you can scan them with a decent scanner and get image results that are as good as, or superior to, the best digital images. I've done this with an Epson scanner at 2400ppi and 6x6 slides. The results were simply awesome, and just as good as, if not better than, the best digital images I've seen.

And while it is possible to achieve these results with 35mm slides as well, the problem with digitizing 35mm slides so they will rival high-quality digital images is it takes a very expensive scanner to achieve the best results.


Reply

"sensor" size is matter really I had lucky I saw contact copies from large format cameras taken 80 yrs before sharpness , quality is unbelievable really. To invest digitize 35mm format not so smart if we can increase quality very easily with medium format or large format. Medium format folders are cheap, portable and produce awesome images. If I will have more money I will take Fuji 645 with 60mm lens or Fuji 6x9 with wide lens.

I read somewhere on net scanner technology is continuously improved , so slides what is captured today 10 yrs later will still available for input to better scanners. Certainly digitally captured images can't improve 10 yrs later.


Reply

****I read somewhere on net scanner technology is continuously improved , so slides what is captured today 10 yrs later will still available for input to better scanners. Certainly digitally captured images can't improve 10 yrs later.***

Well I would have thought there is no big money to be made in film and scanners and it's a dead end.


Reply

A dead-end -- I'm not so sure, especially when we consider that there are many hundreds of millions of photographic images stored as slides and negatives throughout the world, and that more and more people will want to have them digitized. Perhaps not a growth market anymore, but I don't think a dead end.

The problem with using a DSLR to dupe slides, which is what I've begun to do, is they can never be sharper than the resolution of the DSLR. And since it can be shown mathematically that a 36x24mm image with very fine grained film can hold up to 40mp of information, there is still room for better scanner technology yet.

I suspect that compact dedicated scanners will become more popular -- especially ones like the 7200ppi and higher Plusteks -- although I suspect these Plusteks don't deliver anywhere near 7200ppi -- but the technology will continue to improve.


Reply

Well, I went ahead and bid on a clean Yashica Mat 124 just a few minutes ago. And I won the auction for $99US. That's a good price for a Mat 124, so I can't complain.

点击此处在 eBay 上查看

I'm looking forward to its arrival. I even have a roll of 220 that's been in my freezer for years that I'll put through it. Should be interesting. In the meantime, though, I will still keep my eyes open for good prices for medium format SLR outfits. Maybe I should rethink my bias against 645. The fact that your average 645 camera is not much bigger than a 35mm camera is a big plus as well.


Reply

Unfortunately Excalibur has right if no money anymore in film and scanner technology it will be a dead end. This forum and many others especially big ones like flickr albums can be help a lot to keep alive film.

Need to change thinking of people most of them easily invest 1000-2000 USD to a new DSLR but lot less willing to invest half amount to scanner + camera+ film . Personally I never seen better long distance shoots that taken with MF camera + slide. Closer distance is different I like DSLR output better.


Reply

***A dead-end -- I'm not so sure, especially when we consider that there are many hundreds of millions of photographic images stored as slides and negatives throughout the world, and that more and more people will want to have them digitized. Perhaps not a growth market anymore, but I don't think a dead end.***

Well I was really referring to developing new films and scanners (or anything related to film).
Drum scanner technology is about 10 years old, where is the 32,000 asa film Kodak was thinking about, and home flat bed scanning hasn't improved in leaps and bounds.

Scan with old el cheapo Epson 2480 (my first neg scanner bought s/h for £8 )
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/2480test547.jpg

Scan with expensive Epson V750 pro:-
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/canon28.jpg

So most of joe public wanting to convert old negs to jpgs will not be spending £500 on a V750, so what's the incentive for Epson to bring out a better V950 for keen amateurs as the pros, I would think, are using drum scanners.


Reply

***Maybe I should rethink my bias against 645. The fact that your average 645 camera is not much bigger than a 35mm camera is a big plus as well.***

RB67:-
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/img103.jpg

Bronica Etrs:-
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/img504.jpg


Reply

Excalibur 写道:

Well I was really referring to developing new films and scanners (or anything related to film).
Drum scanner technology is about 10 years old, where is the 32,000 asa film Kodak was thinking about, and home flat bed scanning hasn't improved in leaps and bounds.


Drum scanner technology is about 25 years old now - these haven't improved much since line scanners arrived at grain resolution. Scanning technology is good enough - the real problem that we have is that modern capitalism/consumerism has the management ignore markets that have no intrinsic growth factor. We might get stranded with no more new scanners at all simply because it is impossible to sell more of a new scanner than of the preceding model.

Given that nobody has ever made a 1600 ASA film (anything faster than 1000 only arrives there though push processing), a almost six stop faster film would not even have happened in the complete absence of digital - that is in all likelyhood above the absolute physical limits for silver. But the Ektar 100 treatment (which gave it a two stop speed increase from 25), created a technically feasible and relatively easy path towards a true 3200 film - and I have my doubts whether we'll ever see that.


最后由 Sevo 于 周一 12月 07, 2009 12:00 pm 编辑;共编辑 2 次


Reply

My advice on medium format is:
buy a camera where film handling is easy. Pentacon 6 cameras are great because they are cheap, but you need to place a lot of care with film handling if you want to avoid overlapping frames. Same with Kiev 66 cameras I am told.
Other medium format cameras may cost more but if you are serious about medium format use, making a small investment for a good folder or for a Pentax 645 might be worth to avoid film handling frustrations.
Pentacon 6 however has a big plus side: it has one of the longest register distances, and so its lenses are compatible (via adapter) to nearly all the major medium format systems. Given the affordable prices of Pentacon 6 lenses, this allows for starting a full lens system with not much money.
I for instance have now the COntax 645, but thanks to an adapter I can use all my Pentacon 6 lenses on it. Sure I don't have automation, but I have all focal lenghts covered without the need to buy expensive Contax lenses (I might still get them some in the future for my pleasure... but that's another matter)


Reply

***Given that nobody has ever made a 1600 ASA film (anything faster than 1000 only arrives there though push processing), a almost six stop faster film would not even have happened in the complete absence of digital - that is in all likelyhood above the absolute physical limits for silver. But the Ektar 100 treatment (which gave it a two stop speed increase from 25), created a technically feasible and relatively easy path towards a true 3200 film - and I have my doubts whether we'll ever see that.***

Well IIRC might be something about "High-Speed Positive-Working Photothermographic System" and 25,000 asa:-

http://www.patentstorm.us/patents/7198889.html


Reply

Excalibur 写道:
Scan with old el cheapo Epson 2480 (my first neg scanner bought s/h for £8 )
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/2480test547.jpg

Scan with expensive Epson V750 pro:-
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/canon28.jpg

So most of joe public wanting to convert old negs to jpgs will not be spending £500 on a V750, so what's the incentive for Epson to bring out a better V950 for keen amateurs as the pros, I would think, are using drum scanners


Actually, your photos show what the incentive is -- or should be. The fact that the V750's scans are not all that much better than the 2450s should be shouting to Epson's engineers in ALL CAPS that they need to improve their scanning resolutions.

I don't want to hear from them that it can't be done because I know it can. One relatively simple way they can drastically improve resolution is to switch from a panfocal lens to one that can be manually focused through the controlling software. That's it. Or they can switch to a panfocus lens that really is in focus at the necessary distances from the glass. The current lenses are more like pinhole optics -- the whole object is in focus, but not really sharp anywhere.

There are many quite frustated users of high-end Epson and other brands of scanners who are unhappy because their scanners do not deliver NEARLY the amount of resolution that is claimed. Your V750 delivers about 2300 ppi. My 4990 delivers about 2000 ppi. This is not acceptable in my view.

So what Epson, Canon, HP, Microtek and the others need to do is work on getting their actual resolution values up to where they are equivalent to clamined values. If a scanner touts 4800 ppi resolution, I want 4800 ppi resolution.


Reply

Orio 写道:
My advice on medium format is:
buy a camera where film handling is easy. Pentacon 6 cameras are great because they are cheap, but you need to place a lot of care with film handling if you want to avoid overlapping frames. Same with Kiev 66 cameras I am told.
Other medium format cameras may cost more but if you are serious about medium format use, making a small investment for a good folder or for a Pentax 645 might be worth to avoid film handling frustrations.
Pentacon 6 however has a big plus side: it has one of the longest register distances, and so its lenses are compatible (via adapter) to nearly all the major medium format systems. Given the affordable prices of Pentacon 6 lenses, this allows for starting a full lens system with not much money.
I for instance have now the COntax 645, but thanks to an adapter I can use all my Pentacon 6 lenses on it. Sure I don't have automation, but I have all focal lenghts covered without the need to buy expensive Contax lenses (I might still get them some in the future for my pleasure... but that's another matter)


Thanks for the perspective. Yeah, as I was browsing through the Pentacon/Praktica/Exacta/Kiev listings on eBay, I saw many cheap lenses, and I was figuring that they're actually very good optics.

As it turns out -- and I did mention this above -- I came across a Yashica Mat 124 -- a camera that's been high on my wish list because of both performance and price -- and won it at auction. So now, at least I have one MF camera. Or I will in a few days. Still, I will continue to look for good prices on modular MF systems. And since I guess I shouldn't rule out 645, the most economical system in 645 format at this time seems to be the Bronica ETR-series. I worked as an assistant for a while for a wedding photographer who used a Bronica SQA as a second camera -- and this is the one I'd usually use as a second shooter. That camera certainly rendered excellent photos, so I'm guessing an ETR will as well. Although if I do go with an ETR-series camera, it will be the ETRSi.

Also, the more I think about the issue of which modular system to go with, I remind myself that I will most likely be most happy with a system that uses leaf shutter lenses and does not use, or at least depend on, a focal plane shutter -- so I can have flash sync at all speeds. This narrows the field a bit.


Reply

I have Pentax 67, Kowasix, Kowa Super 66 with 2 backs and Kiev 66.
Most versatile in naturephotography is Pentax 67 which can find sometimes guite cheap. I have 55, 75 and 135 macro in Pentax 67 mount. It means 27,5 mm, 37,5 mm and 67,5 mm macro compares to kino format.

Kiev heve some problems with film winding, but is still usable.
If you find some Carl Zeiss Jena lenses in Pentaconsix/Praktisix/Kiev 66 bajonet and the camera is usable it's fine deal. I have CZJ Sonnar and it's suberb lens. Also have Mir 45 and Volna 90.

Kowasix was in it's time cheaper than Praktisix and more reliable. You can use flashgun in all times 1-1/500 s. with kowasix. And lenses are also very good.

cooltouch 写道:
I need some advice because I'm considering some cameras with which I have no experience.

First off, I don't have a lot to spend on this. If I had a bit more, I know what I'd get -- a Bronica SQA or SQAi with metered finder, back(s), and lens. But they're going for more than I can afford.

I have always liked the Yashica Mat TLRs, and the 124 (not the G) is on the top of my list. It's usually affordable, and takes great photos.

But there's this whole other world out there that I'm not familiar with: the Pentacon/Praktica/Keiv 66 cameras and the Kiev 88s. I've heard generally good things about these cameras over the years.

Now, I understand that some models have MLU. That's a big plus, considering the size of a 6x6 mirror. And some are 12-24 capable too.

So, I guess what I'd like to know is, which way would you go if you had to choose between the various East German/Ukranian cameras and a TLR like the Yashica Mat? And most important -- other than the obvious, which is interchangeable lenses, why would you make this choice? Or is lens interchangeability the major reason why you would choose one of the SLRs? And if you would choose an SLR, which one is your preference? I'm specifically interested in any reason why one would prefer one of the Pentacon-style cameras over one like the Kiev 88, for example.

Thanks!


Reply

***There are many quite frustated users of high-end Epson and other brands of scanners who are unhappy because their scanners do not deliver NEARLY the amount of resolution that is claimed. Your V750 delivers about 2300 ppi. My 4990 delivers about 2000 ppi. This is not acceptable in my view.***

...it's a law of diminishing returns for your money....but I'm using my scanner less for 35mm as for 99p can get 36 scanned shots on a CD at the supermarket, after they develope the film for 99p......and the quality is quite good erm well the spots have to be removed in PS.

e.g. supermarket file (1.3mb) from CD ......I was testing a Viv No 77, 28-85, cost £8 with Kodak 400asa film, IMO good enough for a 8X10 print and a computer screen.
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/Photo04_2A.jpg


Reply

IMHO the resolution issue tends to be a red herring with scanners. Or perhaps it is linked to our pixel peeping digital habits. I've made good looking 13 inch wide prints from drug store scans. While certainly more ppi may dig out some detail otherwise lost from the film... I think the problem is elsewhere.

Namely, the contrast at which the scanner achieves these ppi's, and more critically, the overall illumination range, and the contrast aka characteristic aka sensitometric curve. It is in this area where presumably by their own data the manufacturers' better scanners beat their leser ones.

But what ought to be the desired illumination range? B&W film I read is around 10 stops... color film less... photo paper less than that...


Or maybe I'm wrong about the above? At any rate, consider that the best new equipment runs into the thousands (tens of thousands in med fmt digital), and even for us vintage-loving folk film equipment runs into the hundreds easily... with everything a scanner has to do, the prices are cheap and the performance perhaps goes with it.


Reply

***I think the problem is elsewhere.***

Indeed, you pay lot's of money for a new V750 and then find you have to search on google on how to get the best result from a neg in scanning, using crappy film holders and the scanning lens is not AF so you get silly little lumps of plastic to adjust the height of the neg holders to get the sharpest focus.......just another reason why ordinary Joe public prefers digital.